New rules for Central Valley dairy manure face legal challenge

Jim Bradbury, James D. Bradbury, PLLC, and Mattie Meyring, student, Texas A&M University School of Law

California, a large center of dairy production, recently enacted changes on manure practices that are worth understanding for Texas producers. On Sept. 15, the California State Water Board adopted an order making major changes to how Central Valley dairies manage manure to address concerns about adverse effects of nitrate concentrations in groundwater. The order sends the region’s existing Waste

Discharge Requirements (WDRs) back to the Central Valley Water Board for revisions consistent with the recommendations of the order. Following the adoption of the order, five groups representing dairy farmers sued the State Board in Tulare County Superior Court.

What the Order Requires

Under current rules, dairies may apply no more than 1.4 times as much nitrogen to their cropland as their crops can remove. Under the recent order, the revised WDRs maintain this standard but go further to require “progressively more stringent” land application requirements to “provide a structure for incremental reduction in existing dairies’ application of manure” over time.

Existing dairies (those in operation as of Sept. 15) are allowed up to 35 years to comply with the final land application requirements. However, new dairies “must be designed to immediately comply with the most stringent land application rates that have been established by the Central

Valley Water Board.” Importantly, cows added to an existing dairy are treated as new, even when they join an existing herd. As a result, the share of the dairy’s manure that comes from its “existing” herd gets up to 35 years to meet the final land application rates, while the share that comes from an expansion of the herd (which counts as “new”) must immediately comply with the final land application rates.

What the Lawsuit Argues

The dairy groups argue that the State Board overstepped its authority by taking away decisions that belong to the Central Valley Water Board. They contend that, under state law and a statewide pollution policy, the Central Valley Water Board has discretion to set compliance timelines for dairies. They also argue that the region’s Salt and Nitrate Control Program lets the Central Valley Water Board grant compliance exceptions of up to 35 years.

According to the dairy groups, the order bars the Central Valley Water Board from giving new and expanding dairies either a time schedule or an exception to meet the final limits. It also bars any time schedule, even for existing dairies, to meet the 1.4 interim land application limit. The dairy groups add that the order has no evidence that dairies can meet these limits right away. They also claim the order effectively rewrites the regional program without following the required procedures.

What’s Next 

The dairy groups ask the court to vacate the order, or at least the parts that they challenge. In the meantime, the order stays in effect, and its first deadlines arrive in September 2027.

Be the first to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*